Core Three
Non-Western Worlds:
Women's Studies 162
WOMEN IN JAPAN

Spring '97
Instructor
Dr. George L. Pamental (Laurie) Office: Alger 225
Department of Economics & Management Hours: M,W 11-noon,
Phone: 456-8760 (o) 295-5885 (h) By appointment
email:gpamental@grog.ric.edu
Contents
Why Core Three?
There are some of us who love to learn about new things, who are
fascinated by differences, and relish the opportunity to meet new
people, visit new places, sample new foods, and learn new things. We
jump at the opportunity to discuss new ideas and debate different
values. But that's not why this course exists. This course exists
because several of us believe it's good for you. We can't get away
from a simple truth--there is value in knowing about another culture.
And it doesn't make much difference what culture, because the value
comes from the comparisons you will make between whatever culture you
are studying and your own. An important value of studying another
culture comes from the deeper understanding of yourself which
results. This new understanding represents growth, and part of the
growth is the recognition that there are others in the area, state,
country, hemisphere, world, universe who are different, and have just
as much right to their beliefs as we do to ours. Rogers and
Hammerstein, in their musical, South Pacific, deliberately included a
controversial song, which started like this:
"You've got to be taught to hate and fear,
You've got to be taught from year to year,
It's got to be drummed in your dear little ear,
You've got to be carefully taught.
You've got to be taught before it's too late,
Before you are six, or seven or eight,
To hate all the people your relatives hate,
You've got to be carefully taught,
You've got to be carefully taught.
It was controversial because many people did not want to admit
that prejudice exists, a lot of people did not want to admit their
own fears. But to their credit, Rogers and Hammerstein kept the song
in, primarily because it was appropriate to the story - a young Navy
lieutenant from an upper-class home in Philadelphia had fallen in
love with an island native. The young officer recognized a sad truth,
that many of us grow up thinking that "our" way is the "right" way,
and any deviation is to be suspected. So, one value of knowing about
another culture is to be able to get to know someone without
offending him or her.
Another practical value of knowing about a different culture is
the possibility of being offered a job in a firm from another
country. Or, closer to home, there are courses offered here which
involve e-mailing with students from other countries to exchange
information, or even do joint projects. You surely don't want to
offend the person who is your source of information. Further down the
road, you don't want to feel stupid or embarrassed when your own
child asks you a question about a new classmate of theirs.
Other reasons include the very fact of your becoming a college
graduate. In that capacity some will value your opinion valued--after
all, you studied in college. How can you respond intelligently to
questions on important issues in the news, such as immigration
policies, trade disputes with other countries, a local plant closing,
or even deciding whom to vote for in an election. These issues are in
today's papers, they are already among us and need to be addressed.
How should you respond?
When you report for a job interview and discover that the
company's representative is from a particular ethnic background, how
do you respond? When a new family moves next door, how do you
respond? When your son or daughter brings home a new friend, how do
you respond? When you are assigned to work with another employee, how
do you respond? How do you impress your boss when he or she is from a
different ethnic background? How do you treat your employees or the
people who report to you when they are from different backgrounds?
These are some of the reasons why it is important and valuable to be
familiar with other cultures.
Return to Contents
Why Only One Culture?
A good question you may be pondering right about now is how can
all of these questions be answered by a single course. Good question!
They can't. There are thousands of different cultures and languages
out there. But extensive study of a single one of them has a unique
and extremely valuable advantage.
In ancient Greece there was an oracle at Delphi, a place where
citizens could go to consult their deities about the future or get
advice. But the sign over the entryway was very interesting--it said
"Sophrosine--Know thyself." The Greeks realized that before
one could prepare for the future one had to understand oneself, one's
values, beliefs, strengths, weaknesses, likes, dislikes, etc. And
that's the first advantage of studying a single culture--the
comparisons you will be making and the resultant increased
understanding of your own values and beliefs.
It is true that some of this could be accomplished by studying
several different cultures, but the study of one, in depth, provides
us with the exhaustive analysis of our own fundamental beliefs so
necessary to reaching an understanding about others. This exercise,
an exhaustive self-analysis through comparison, can bring home to us
in a powerful way that there are legitimate and understandable
reasons why some others have very different fundamental values. And
it's important to realize that we're not discussing superficial
differences such as clothing or food, but basic behaviors like who we
pray to and what we pray for, or if we pray at all. Things like
touching another person, when, and where. Things like looking another
person in the eye, or not. Things like raising children, speaking the
truth, keeping promises, having sex.
And coming to this understanding through a systematic and detailed
analysis prepares us for doing it again, on our own, when the
occasion calls for it. In other words, the exhaustive analysis not
only deepens our understanding of ourselves and leads us to truly
knowing another culture, but it prepares us for knowing yet others as
well.
Part of this preparation stems from the method of analysis central
to the General Education program. This course, and all the courses in
the program, call for:
- persuasive speaking
- critical analysis and synthesis
- receptive listening
- clear and rhetorically informed writing
- critical and engaged reading
- applications of technology
These are valuable skills and abilities which transcend any
particular course. They will help you in your other coursework and
they will help you outside school.
Why Japan?
Japan has been one of our strongest and most loyal allies for ever
fifty years. It was our defense outpost against the USSR before the
Wall fell. Its dramatic economic success has forced many of our
biggest companies to get better to remain competitive. We all benefit
from the resulting improved products. Its children's outstanding
performance on math and science tests has stimulated the examination
of our own school system.
It is the world's second largest economy, and the one with which,
next to Canada, we trade the most. Yet despite all of this
interaction, we hardly know it, the prototypical stereotypes being
the rapacious businessman and the kimono-clad geisha.
For a country as technologically advanced as Japan is, and with
the highest average family income in the world, we are surprised to
see a social system so at variance with our own. In so many other
countries, technological advancement and wealth have been accompanied
by, if not created by, greater equality between men and women. Not so
Japan.
If we are to coexist as friendly allies and competitors, we must
be able to communicate effectively. And if we are to communicate
effectively, we must understand one another. This course should help
you better understand a country of such intriguing contrasts, ancient
traditions, and modern ways.
About the Course
To understand the Japan of today, we will begin, as they say, at
the beginning. We will go back to the early period of Japan's history
to discover the beginnings of those cultural institutions and
characteristics which are still operative today, influencing
behavior. We will read from Japan's equivalent of the Bible and their
"begats." We'll see that Japan was originally a matriarchy, but by
the time the histories were written it had become as sexist as many
other countries.
We will look at the major periods of Japanese history to identify
those factors which help to define today's Japan and particularly
those which affect Japanese women. Included in this survey will be
the folk heritage and traditions, and the arts, which are so
important to the Japanese.
Once we have identified Japan's major historical roots, we'll look
at those major aspects of a culture which serve to preserve as well
as define its uniqueness--language, religion, education, and the
law--their evolution and their current influence on women.
We will then examine the lives and roles of women in today's
Japan, from the early years to the ending years, to see how modern
Japanese women are viewed and treated, and how they act and cope. We
will finish by looking at some rebels, and some signs of change.
Objectives
- To understand the roles and values of Japanese women, and
their historical development.
- To understand the forces affecting women in Japanese society.
- To gain experience and confidence in listening, speaking,
reading, writing, and thinking critically.
- To know yourself, clarify your own values and beliefs, and
learn to accept those who are different.
Texts
Elisabeth Bumiller. The Secrets of Mariko: A Year in the
Life of a Japanese Woman and Her Family. New York: Times Books,
1995.
George L. Pamental. Daijohbu: Learning from the
Japanese. Revised edition. Unpublished manuscript. 1996
Edwin O. Reischauer and Marius B. Jansen. The Japanese
Today: Change and Continuity. Enarged Edition. Cambridge: The
Belknap Press of Harvard University, 1995.
Yukiko Tanaka. Contemporary Portraits of Japanese Women.
Westport, CT: Praeger, 1995.
Method/Requirements
Writing and discussion will be the major components of the course,
as follows:
Class Participation
There will be a variety of activities taking place in class, from
criticising the writing of your groupmates to preparing a group
analysis. Your active involvement (not just merely showing up) is
required. More important, though, will be the quality of that
involvement. Hence you will be evaluated on the logic of your
arguments, your supporting rationale, how well you understood the
weekly reading/viewing, your ability to be critical of another's work
but express the criticism in a way that does not offend, and your
ability to take criticism constructively and not be offended.
Reading Analysis
There will be assigned readings, at first for each class, and then
weekly. You will write a 1-2 page critical reflection based upon your
reaction to each reading. What is most important to remember is that
this is not a summary. Nor is it simply an emotional reaction. It is
not sufficient to write that you donÕt like something, or that you
would not accept something, or even that you believe something is
wrong. Rather, what you are writing is a critical reflection--you
must give reasons (not feelings) for your views. Some questions you
might ask as you read are ÒWhat do I feel about this?Ó ÒWould I like
to be treated that way?Ó ÒIs this behavior/treatment wrong (and on
what basis do I make this claim), or is it just different?Ó ÒWould
this be tolerated in the U.S.?Ó ÒIs Japan the only country in which
this takes place?Ó ÒHow does this compare to the U.S.?Ó These
questions and comments then can become the source of your writing.
In class, in small groups, you will exchange your analyses and
read each other's and discuss. You should take this opportunity to
get and give help with your writing as well. The papers will not be
graded for form but you shouldn't ignore grammar, spelling, etc. Do
them on your computer so they can be edited by you and read by others
more easily, and so you'll have them in one place to use for your
term paper.
These analyses will not be graded, but failure to submit one will
result in a reduction from the final course grade. They are worth 28%
of that grade, which you will earn automatically if all 14 are turned
in on time.
Short Research Papers
You will have a choice of two out of four research topics.
Paper 1:
a. Early, Classical, and Tokugawa period (up to 1850)
contributions to the roles and treatment of women in modern Japanese
society; or
b. Meiji and Occupation period (1850-1950) contributions to the
roles and treatment of women in modern Japanese society.
Paper 2:
How modern Japanese women have been affected by a particular
social institution--education, religion, language, the bureaucracy,
the arts, folk tales.
Note that these are research papers, not merely a re-statement of
the readings. You are expected to use outside sources (at least four,
but no texts, encyclopedias (hard copy or internet), or Time Life or
other series) to support your views. Naturally, since this will be
the first time most of you will have investigated the topic, most of
what you write will require an indication of the source, i.e.
footnotes or endnotes. (You are to use Chicago style as given in Kate
Turabian's A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, and
Dissertations.) Don't be surprised that nearly every paragraph you
write has at least one reference, and often more. A bibliography is
also required.
The requirements are a detailed outlline (how you propose
organizing the paper), one or more early drafts and a final draft. In
addition, you will write formal critiques of the work of two
classmates (and they of you). The papers will be done in stages as
follows.
- Write detailed outline outside class
- Discussion in class
- Write early draft(s) outside class
- Exchange second or third drafts in class
- Read others' work, write formal critique outside class
- Discuss formal critique in class
- Write final draft outside class
First, read. Collect information. Once you have enough information
(it varies by individual) begin writing, either an outline or just
your thoughts. After you've developed an idea of how you want to
proceed, prepare your outline in as detailed a form as you can. Bring
two copies to class where, in groups of three, you will exchange
material so that two of your classmates will read your material and
you will read theirs. I will provide you with an evaluation sheet. As
a group you will then discuss all three outlines, offering
encouragement and advice. Be critical, and try to give and obtain as
much helpful advice as you can.
After receiving formal criticism on the outline, given and
discussed in class, you will take this information home and continue
writing. Once you have a decent draft (it may be the second or third,
with some parts even more), bring three copies to class to exchange
on the appointed date. You'll take your groupmates' drafts home,
read, and prepare a formal critique. I'll provide a form for that,
too. These will be brought to class for group discussion.
Finally, you'll take the last round of critiques home and write
your final draft. Thus, each student will have the benefit of two
formal criticisms, plus group discussion, to be used in preparation
of the final draft.
The papers will be evaluated based upon the material presented,
your understanding of the material, the logic of your presentation,
how well you support your views with rationale, and the quality of
your writing- clarity, simplicity, and mechanics (spelling,
punctuation, and grammar). You will earn credit for the first four,
and lose credit (1/2 point per error) for the last.
Term Paper
This will be a term-long investigation in which you will make use
of the class discussions, videos, and reading material, along with
outside research, to write about the changes taking place within
Japanese society and the effects those changes are having on women.
You will be required to focus on four of the following roles or
occupation or status groups:
- young unmarried working woman
- young married woman with no children
- young married woman with child in grammar school
- young married woman with child in high school
- housewife with children away from home
- blue collar worker
- white collar worker
- entrepreneur
- elderly
In effect this will be four mini-papers. The procedure, and
evaluation, will be the same as for the shorter paper.
Return to Contents
General Requirements
& Grading
Class participation is an important part of the course, and much
of what you learn will come from those discussions. Therefore,
attendance is mandatory. Unauthorized absence will result in loss of
participation credit and a penalty deducted from the final grade.
The short papers should be 4-5 pages of text and the term paper
10-12 (about 3 pages per group). Use 1" margins on all four sides and
10 or 12 point type--this syllabus is in Helvetica, 10 point--of the
san serif variety. San Serif, Geneva or Helvetica are available in
nearly all word processing programs.
Papers will be computer generated. If you use a dot matrix
printer, do not use one with a dull or worn out ribbon. There
should be a cover sheet with your name, the date, the class, and the
subject. Back up your file every few paragraphs, and make a second
copy on a separate disk. If you are using the labs at the
college, make sure to do this, and do not wait until the day the
material is due to print your copies. There are too many things that
can go wrong to wait until the last minute.This is particularly
important, since no late papers will be accepted, and "the
computer ate my file" is not an acceptable excuse. Plan ahead and
save headaches. Equally important, you need to have the material in
time for your group mates to read it in class.
Grading will be based on the following weights:
- Class participation 15%
- Weekly Analysis 28% (automatic, if all assignments completed
on time)
- Short paper #1 16%
- Short paper #2 16%
- Term paper 25%
Return to Contents
Weekly Schedule
|
Wk
|
Topic
|
Due*
|
|
1
|
Introduction to the course, mythology, Early, Classical ,
and Tokugawa historical eras
|
|
|
2
|
Meiji, Occupation, and Post-occupation historical eras,
introduction to women in Japan
|
|
|
3
|
An "average" woman, birth of feminism
|
Term Paper Topics / Short paper outline
|
|
4
|
Religion and Language
|
Exchange short paper drafts
|
|
5
|
Education
|
Discuss short paper formal critiques
|
|
6
|
Education and Employment
|
Turn in short paper
|
|
7
|
Communication: The Individual and the Group
|
Term paper outline
|
|
8
|
Spring Break
|
|
|
9
|
Motherhood
|
Short paper outline
|
|
10
|
Marriage and the Family
|
Exchange short paper drafts
|
|
11
|
Women at Work
|
Short paper formal critiques
|
|
12
|
TV, Pornography, and the Elderly
|
Turn in short paper
|
|
13
|
Politics
|
|
|
14
|
Feminism and the Law
|
Exchange term paper drafts
|
|
15
|
Summary / Reflection
|
Term paper formal critiques
|
* Above assignments due on Wednesdays. Weekly Two-page
Reading Analyses are due on the dates indicated on the hand out.
(Generally each Monday)
Return to Contents
Reading Assignments
|
Wed
|
1/29
|
Reischauer
Pamental
|
Chapts. 3-6
Chapt. 1
|
Early Japan, Feudalism
Mikako
|
|
Mon
|
2/3
|
Reischauer
Pamental
|
Chapts. 7,8,10,11,13,16
Chapt. 2
|
Meiji, Occupation, Post-occupation, The group, The
Individual
Mikako
|
|
Wed
|
2/5
|
Iwao
Fujimura
Pamental
|
Chapt. 1
pp. xvii-xxvii
Chapt. 3
|
Myths and realities
Overview
Women in the Family
|
|
Mon
|
2/10
|
Iwao
Fujimura
Pamental
|
Chapt. 2
pp. 323-352
Chapt. 4, ii
|
The Story of Akiko
Japan's First Phase of Feminism
Keiko and Okaasan
|
|
Mon
|
2/17
|
Reischauer
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapts. 19,38
Chapt. 5
pp. 15-42
|
Religion / Language
Young Women
Women's Image and Place in Japanese Buddhism / Aspects of
Sexism in Language
|
|
Mon
|
2/24
|
Reischauer
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapt. 18
Chapt. 6
pp. 93-124
|
Education
Fusako
Challenges to Education for Girls and Women in Modern Japan:
Past and Present / Sexism and Gender Stereotyping in Schools
|
|
Mon
|
3/3
|
Reischauer
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapt. 33
Chapt. 7, iv-vi
pp. 125-154, 295-309
|
The Employment System
Farm Women
College Women Today: Options and Dilemmas / Work, Education
and the Family
|
|
Mon
|
3/10
|
Iwao
Pamental
|
Chapt. 4
Chapt. 8, i
|
Communication and Crisis
Rotary Membership
|
S P R I N G B R E A K
|
|
Mon
|
3/24
|
Iwao
Fujimura
Pamental
|
Chapt. 5
pp. 199-213
Chapt. 9
|
Motherhood and the Home
The Mystique of Motherhood
Amatarasu, Norie, and Okusan
|
|
Mon
|
3/31
|
Iwao
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapt. 3
Chapt. 10
pp. 183-199
|
Marriage and the Family
Junko and the Sarariman's Wives
Marriage and the Family: Past and Present
|
|
Mon
|
4/7
|
Iwao
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapts. 6,7
Chapt. 11
pp. 271-294
|
Work as Option / Work as Profession
Yuki and Tamoe
Female Workers: An Overview of Past and Current Trends
|
|
Mon
|
4/14
|
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapt. 12
pp. 75-92, 213-228, 255-270, 309-322
|
Makiko and Okaasan
Women and Television: Portrayal of Women in Mass Media /
Care of the Elderly: a Women's Issue / Pornographic Culture
and Sexual Violence / The Plight of Asian Migrant Women
Working in Japan's Sex Industry
|
|
Mon
|
4/21
|
Reischauer
Iwao
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapts. 23, 26
Chapt. 8
Chapt. 13
pp. 365-392
|
The Diet / Political Parties
Politics and No Power
Fumiko, Nanako, and Junko
From the Home to the Political Arena / Profiles of Two
Assemblywomen
|
|
Mon
|
4/28
|
Pamental
Fujimura
|
Chapt. 14
pp. 3-14, 323-364
|
Kazuko and Friends
The Strugge for Legal Rights and Reforms / Japan's First
Phase of Feminism / The New Feminist Movement in Japan,
1970-1990 / Legal Challenges to the Status Quo
|
*Written Analyses due on each date.
Return to Contents
Selected Bibliography
Fiction
Ariyoshi Sawako. The Doctor's Wife
________. The River Ki
Phyllis Birnbaum, translator. Rabbits, Crabs, Etc.: Stories by
Japanese Women
Murasaki Shikibu. The Tale of Genji.
Sei Shonagon. The Pillow Book of Sei Shonagon.
Tanizaki Junichiro. The Makioka Sisters.
_______. Naomi.
Yuuko Tsushima. A Child of Fortune
Banana Yoshimoto. Kitchen.
Non-Fiction
Anne Allison. Nightwork: Sexuality, Pleasure, and
Corporate
Azuma, Hiroshi, et al. Child Development and Education in
Japan
Ben-Ari, Eyal, Moeran, Brian and Valentine, James, eds. Unwrapping
Japan
Benedict, Ruth. The Chrysanthemum and the Sword
Mary Brinton. Women and the economic Miracle
Buckley, Roger Japan Today, 2nd ed.
Bumiller, Elisabeth, The Secrets of Mariko
Cherry, Kittredge. Womansword: What Japanese Words Say About
Women
Christopher, R.C. The Japanese Patterns of Behavior
________. The Japanese Mind
Clark, Scott, Japan, a View from the Bath
Cole, Robert. Japanese Blue Collar
________. Work, Mobility, & Participation
Jane Condon. A Half Step Behind: Japanese Women of the
'80's
________ and Kurata, K. What's Japanese About Japan?
Confucius. The Analects. Translated with an Introduction by
D.C. Lau. London: Penguin, 1979.
Coomaraswamys, Ananada Hinduism and Buddhism
Davidson, Cathy. 36 Views of Mt. Fuji
de Bary, W.T. East Asian Civilizations: A Dialogue in 5 Stages
Doi, Takeo. The Anatomy of Self: The Individual Versus
Society
________. The Anatomy of Dependence
Edwards, Walter. Modern Japan Through its Weddings
Enright, D.J. The World of Dew: Aspects of Living Japan
Fallows, James. More Like Us
Frost, Ellen. For Richer, For Poorer
Fukutake, Tadashi Japanese Society Today
________. The Japanese Social Structure...
Greenfeld, Karl, Speed Tribes: Days and Nights with Japan's Next
Generation
Hall, E.T. Hidden Differences: Doing Business With the
Japanese
Hall, J.W. and R. Beardsley. Twelve Doors to Japan
________. History of Japan
________. Japan: From Prehistory to Modern Times
Halloran, Richard. Japan: Images and Realities
Hunter, Janet, ed. Japanese Women Working
Imamura, Anne E. Urban Japanese Housewives: At Home and in the
Community
Inoue, Yasushi. Chronicle of My Mother
Itasaka, Gen, translated by Jon H. Loftus, Gates to Japan: Its
People and Society
Lebra, Takie S. Japanese Patterns of Behavior
________. Japanese Culture and Behavior
________. "Gender and Culture in the Japanese Political Economy:
Self-Portrait of Prominent
Businesswomen" in The Political Economy of Japan. Volume 3:
Cultgural and Social Dynamics. Edited
by Shumpei Kumon and Henry Rosovsky. Stanford, CA: Stanford
University Press, 1992.
Jeannie Lo. Office Ladies, Factory Women: Life and Work at a
Japanese Company
Mitchell, Douglas. Amaeru: The Expression of Reciprocal Dependency
. .
Nakane, Chie. Japanese Society
Nakano Makiko. Makiko's Diary: A Merchant Wife in 1910
Kyoto
Norbeck, Edward. Changing Japan 2nd ed
Passin, Herbert Society and Education in Japan
Philip, Leila. The Road Through Miyama
Edwin O. Reischauer and Marius B. Jansen. The Japanese Today:
Change and Continuity. Enlarged
Glenda Roberts. Staying on the Line: Blue Collar Women...
Rohlen, Thomas. Japan's High Schools
Donald Richie. Geisha, Gangster, Neighbor, Nun: Scenes from
Japanese Lives.
Frederik L. Schodt. Manga! Manga! The World of Japanese
Comics. Tokyo: Kodansha, 1983.
Sansom, George Japan: A Short Cultural History
________. History of Japan, 3 vols.
Schoppa, Leonard. Education Reform in Japan
Smith, Robert Japanese Society: Tradition, Self, and the Social
Order
Smith, Robert J. and Wiswell, Ella Lury. The Women of Suye
Mura
E. Patricia Tsurumi. Factory Girls: Women in the Thread Mills of
Meiji Japan
Varley, Paul Japanese Culture
Vogel, Ezra. Japan as Number One: Lessons for America
________. Japan's New Middle Class, rev. ed.
White, Merry The Japanese Educational Challenge
________. The Material Child
Return to Contents